Which Two Current Football Pundits Had the Most Success as Players?

The world of football punditry has never been more beloved. Back in the day, those who were chosen to provide expert analysis on the weekend’s action were much maligned. So much so in fact that legendary manager Brian Clough once unloaded on the recently deceased John Motson live on national television in the UK. But nowadays, plenty has changed.
Don’t get us wrong, there are still a number of pundits out there who would have to battle it out against watching paint dry for the most boring pastime. BT Sports’ punditry team springs to mind, with the likes of Michael Owen, Owen Hargreaves, and Rio Ferdinand regularly boring viewers into submission. But Sky Sports certainly have their pundits nailed down to a tee.
Roy Keane, Gary Neville, Jamie Carragher, and Micah Richards regularly provide entertainment to the masses. The latter of those two also present America’s coverage of the UEFA Champions League, alongside Thierry Henry and the brilliant Kate Abdo, whose jibes at poor Micah make you feel for the former Manchester City ‘star’.
But of all of the aforementioned, which of them had the most success as a player? Let’s take a look. And sorry Micah, you don’t feature on this list.

Thierry Henry
Former Arsenal and France striker Thierry Henry will go down in history as one of the greatest strikers that have ever lived. The former AS Monaco youngster won all that there was to win as a player, and he was beloved at every club he turned out for throughout his 20-year professional career. In fact, The Gunners have not tasted English top-flight success since their iconic number 14 left the club back in 2008.
Betway’s Premier League betting odds made the North London club the favourites for their first crown in 19 years this season. However, the back-to-back surrendering of two-goal leads, firstly against Liverpool and then against West Ham United, has seen reigning champions Manchester City narrow the gap to Mikel Arteta’s men at the summit of English football. As such, Pep Guardiola’s Blues are now the favourites to pick up their fifth English title in six years, just as they were last season.
When Henry was wearing that famous red shirt, however, things were much different. He won the Premier League twice for the club, including that famous Invincible season, which will go down in history as one of the Premier League’s greatest ever teams. He also twice won the FA Cup with the Gunners, as well as leading them to the UEFA Champions League final in 2006, where they ultimately lost out to Barcelona.
‘Titi’ would eventually get his hands on the famous ‘Big Eared’ trophy three years later as a part of the team that defeated his Arsenal side. And if that wasn’t enough, he has also won the World Cup and the European Championships with France.

Gary Neville
“Nobody wants to grow up to be a Gary Neville.” That’s what colleague Jamie Carragher once said on a broadcast of Monday Night Football for Sky Sports in the UK. However, if they took one look at his trophy cabinet, maybe they would. While the older Neville brother may not have been the most glamorous of footballers, he certainly knew how to win titles.
The former England fullback only ever featured for Manchester United throughout his 19-year career, racking up a whopping 602 appearances for the club in all competitions. He also made an additional 85 appearances for England between 1995 and 2007, and as he aptly put it, was a “stalwart” at right back for both club and country.
In terms of trophies, there aren’t many players that have ever lived that have more trophies to their name than Gary Neville. He won the Premier League on eight separate occasions, as well as winning both the FA Cup and the League Cup on three occasions. He is a two-time UEFA Champions League winner and was a crucial part of Manchester United’s famous treble-winning squad of 1999. Not bad Gary, not bad at all.