US Managers in the EPL

Americans and football have always been uneasy bed fellows. Suspicion of the other party went both ways, but things are slowly changing. More and more people are playing the game in the States, their league is becoming more established, more competitive, more… like we have in the rest of the world. On the other side of the coin, and partly as a result of and partly the drive behind it, more American-born players are playing at top European leagues. There are currently three in the Premier League, and six in the Championship for example.
The number of American managers however is a different story for a couple of reasons. There is going to be an inevitable lag. Being a coach naturally means you have been immersed in and around the game for many years, to build up the broad knowledge and skills essential for the role. There is also a lot more risk involved for the hiring club. It is one thing hiring a midfielder with potential, it is entirely another hiring a manager to take your club forward (or backward). The high-profile appointment of Jesse Marsch at Leeds has thrown the spotlight on this issue, so let’s look at Marsch and the previous American managers who have coached in the EPL.
Jesse Marsch
Marsch ticks all the boxes in terms of a young progressive coach with experience and success managing in Europe at a relatively high level. It is only his nationality that has raised a few eyebrows.If he had been Italian, Spanish or from any other “traditional” footballing nation then it would barely be a talking point. He had a decent, if not spectacular career as a player, where he notched up 14 seasons as a midfielder in the MLS, picking up two caps along the way. His first coaching role was with the US team, as assistant to Bob Bradley who he had played under.
His first real success came at the second club he managed, New York Red Bulls, where he won more games than any other coach in the club’s history. That put him in the spotlight and a move to RB Leipzig followed where he worked under current Manchester United head coach Ralf Rangnick.
His first head coach role in Europe was at RB Salzburg. There he achieved the double, winning almost 70% of his games, before making the step back to RB Leipzig, this time as the main man. Then this move to Leeds came up where he was parachuted straight into a relegation dogfight. For those betting on the Premier League, a Leeds defeat was for several weeks one of the first games on their acca, butMarsch has made them harder to beat, picking up a vital win in the six-pointer against Norwich along the way. It will be interesting to see how Marsch gets on at Leeds, and in a very real way, he will set the new standard for American managers for a long time to come.
Bob Bradley
The most famous American to have managed in the EPL prior to Marsch was the man who was instrumental in his career as both a player and manager. Again eyebrows were raised when Bradley was made manager at Swansea and safe to say it was not a move that worked out for anyone involved. He lasted just 11 games which spanned 85 days. Not all of that can be put down to Bradley, the club were in a poor situation on and off the field, but it certainly played into the narrative about American coaches.
David Wagner
The other American manager who has plied his trade in the EPL is often forgotten about in those terms and with good reason. He was German. Born in Germany to a German mother and Thai father, his mother remarried an American before he was born. Wagner won 1 cap for the German U21’s and 8 for the US team. As manager of Huddersfield he took them up into the EPL and then kept them there in what has been described as one of the greatest Premier League survival stories. Unfortunately it did not last and with the club adrift at the foot of the table, the two parted company midway through the following season.