Premier League Golden Boot Odds: Can Isak or Haaland Catch Shearer’s Historic Record?
Alexander Isak’s £130 million move to Liverpool has not only set a new British transfer record but also reignited the debate over whether anyone can surpass Alan Shearer’s iconic 260 Premier League goals.
Shearer, a Premier League icon and still the league’s all-time leading scorer, set his record during spells at Blackburn Rovers and boyhood club Newcastle United, cementing his status as one of English football’s greatest strikers.
The Odds are Against Isak
The switch from Newcastle to Anfield marks a pivotal moment in the Swede’s career. He arrives with 54 goals in 86 league appearances and now finds himself in a side built to create chances. Liverpool’s relentless attacking style could help him close the gap on some of the league’s greatest scorers faster than many expect.
But chasing down Shearer’s tally is no small task. Isak would need to average 20 goals a season for the next decade to get there, a feat the markets seem unconvinced he can achieve. The latest Golden Boot odds on the bet way app, the all-in-one hub for live sports betting and casino play, have him at 13/1 for the 2025/26 season.
So, if not Isak, which of the current stars is most likely to threaten Shearer’s long-standing record?
Haaland: The Machine with Time on His Side
If anyone looks equipped to rewrite the record books, it’s Erling Haaland. The Norwegian has already scored 88 goals in just 100 Premier League appearances, a rate that makes Shearer’s 260 look far less untouchable than it once did. To match the Newcastle legend, Haaland needs 172 more, a total he could reach in just six or seven seasons if he maintains his current strike rate.
Tellingly, the markets on the bet way app back the 25-year-old to dominate the Golden Boot race again, with Haaland odds-on at 10/11 this season after a strong start in front of goal, including a brace against Wolves on matchday one.
The question isn’t whether Haaland will keep scoring but whether he’ll stay in England long enough to finish the job. A move to Spain could halt his pursuit, but if he commits to City and the Premier League, as he has suggested, there’s every chance Shearer will finally have company at the top.
Kane: The Legend Abroad
Harry Kane’s decision to leave Tottenham for Bayern Munich put his Premier League tally on ice at 213 goals, still a distant 47 short of Shearer’s 260. If he were still in England, the discussion would be about when — not if — he’d take the crown. Now, it’s more complicated.
Kane remains one of the most prolific forwards in the world and is currently 1/2 favourite to be Bundesliga top scorer according to the bet way app, but those goals won’t count toward the record.
Should he return to the Premier League in the next few years, he’d need to average 15 a season for three campaigns to close the gap. At 32 years old, it’s possible, but the clock is ticking and every year away makes Shearer’s total look that little bit safer. Additionally, Kane would also need to join a club willing to accommodate his deeper role, as he now drops into midfield more often and no longer has the pace to stretch top-flight defences
The reality is that Kane’s move in search of trophies in Germany has, in all likelihood, cost him the chance of making history.
Salah: The Consistent Challenger Nearing the End
Mohamed Salah sits level with Andy Cole on 187 Premier League goals but whether he can keep climbing the list is less certain. At his usual pace of around 20 league goals a season, he could break the 200-goal mark within a year, but matching Shearer’s tally would still take at least four more prolific campaigns.
With his 34th birthday coming up next summer and constant talk of a move to the Saudi Pro League, the window to chase the record is narrowing. The bet way app reflects that reality, pricing Salah at 10/1 for the Golden Boot this season. Another strong campaign would keep him among the elite, but the chances of catching Shearer feel slimmer by the year.
The Enduring Greatness of Shearer
What makes Shearer’s record so hard to touch is that it was built on a mix of talent, consistency and loyalty that feels rare today. He stayed in the Premier League for his entire career, turning down moves abroad and putting up 20-goal seasons year after year. That longevity, combined with ruthless finishing, is what set him apart.
A big part of that success also came from the spot. Shearer converted 56 of the 65 penalties he took for Blackburn and Newcastle, an incredible rate of more than 80 per cent. Those goals kept his tallies ticking even when chances were harder to come by and ensured that lean spells never lasted long.
Modern stars like Haaland or Isak may have the ability to get close, but the nature of today’s game makes a similar career arc unlikely. For now, the man from Newcastle remains the benchmark, the Premier League’s original goal machine and still its ultimate hero. As the season unfolds, the bet way app remains the place to track the odds and see who might make history next.