How the absence of fans is affecting clubs during COVID-19
If you’ve been following the action in the Premier League this season, you might not have realised that something was different. With cameras following the ball and crowd noises played below the commentary, it can take a minute or two to remember that no fans are present. Broadcasters do their best to cover up the lack of fans, but once you catch a glimpse of those empty seats, the illusion is shattered.
When the lockdown was relaxed in the early summer, many supporters were hoping to get back to going to games in person by the autumn. Even the UK Government thought this was a possibility, with plans for limited crowds at games in place for October. Unfortunately, the infection rate of the virus has begun to creep up again and these plans have been shelved — the current forecast is that fans won’t be able to return to matches until March 2021 at the earliest (BBC).
With no crowds in attendance for at least a huge portion of the season, clubs are now facing a long stretch of lonely football with zero atmosphere. With this in mind, here are some of the ways that a long-term absence of fans could begin to affect the sport.
Top players could look elsewhere
Try — if you can — to recall what it was like when a team scored a goal pre-pandemic. There would be a huge roar from the crowd and the players would typically run over to celebrate in front of their admiring audience. There was always a real connection between the supporters and beloved player who was playing well. Now, if a goal is scored, there is a vacuum of silence. A number of Premier League players have already said that playing in an empty stadium is just not the same.
So, if the players are very much missing out on playing in front of their club’s fans, does it stand to reason that this could become a factor they consider when deciding on their future? For instance, if the UK continues to struggle with COVID-19, could we see an exodus of talent to other nations that have the virus under enough control to allow crowds to return? We may also see top names favour leagues with their football economy back up and running when it comes to choosing who to sign for.
If the current best-case scenario were to happen, and crowds were allowed back in March, I imagine this won’t become much of an issue. But if the ban is extended for the foreseeable future, we may see it begin to affect player decisions as soon as the summer transfer window.
The home advantage could disappear
It’s a widely accepted fact that, with a partisan crowd backing the home team, they have the home advantage as those fans roar on their club. However, when this is taken away, there isn’t that famous twelfth man spurring the side on to victory, which could prove catastrophic for some clubs. This begs the question: if there is a team that relies on strong home performances with their fans backing them, will they end up earning less points over a season with no-one there?
While the current situation is unprecedented, we can look at a famous example for some insight: when West Ham moved to the London Stadium in 2016. Many fans claimed the new stadium just didn’t have the same atmosphere as the Boleyn Ground, with bigger space not channelling the home support the right way. Planetfootball crunched the numbers and found that in the season before the move, the Hammers earned an average of 1.79 points per game, but after they moved they only managed 1.32. This seems to suggest a lack of atmosphere can really impact performances.
A huge loss of revenue
Undoubtedly, the lack of crowds at football matches will result in a huge loss of revenue for clubs up and down the country. While this is an immediate problem for Football League teams, who rely on matchday revenue to survive, those in the Premier League have their TV money to insulate them from the loss of what is now only a small slice of their income.
But, what if the absence of supporters forced broadcasters to reconsider the deal that the top clubs rely upon so much? Broadcasters pay exorbitant amounts of money to show Premier League games because of the huge public interest in watching the match. However, if viewers started to turn off games that were underwhelming due to the lack of fans, the broadcasters might have to reconsider how much they’re paying to show games that are no longer an interesting spectacle. Should these TV companies demand lower fees or withhold forthcoming money, some teams will be in trouble.
If the absence of fans from football matches continues well into the future, then clubs could face a new, long-term hardship that hasn’t been seen before. Hopefully, 2021 will bring about a return to something resembling the sport we all love.